Surprising Tips From Experts on Preventing Pickiness in Toddlers

A Timeline for Preventing Pickiness from Pregnancy to 3 Years 

Pickiness can be greatly reduced by repeated exposure, and this exposure can start much, much younger than you might think. We have created a timeline filled with information from baby experts and authors to ensure that your little one will be open to eating various flavors and foods. 

During Pregnancy:

Eat a varied diet, flavors will actually pass through into amniotic fluid. Strong flavors such as garlic, mint, vanilla, and carrot are easily passed through and can introduce your baby to flavors early on. 

"Still in the womb, the growing baby gulps down several ounces of amniotic fluid daily. That fluid surrounding the baby is actually flavored by the foods and beverages the mother has eaten in the last few hours" - Gretchen Cuda-Kroen on NPR

From Birth:

It is also important to eat a varied diet while breastfeeding, flavors may also pass through into milk. This is described as nature's way of introducing children to new food that they will encounter later on in life.

"With mothers who breast-feed, there was a study done showing that if they drank a lot of carrot juice, when those babies first tasted solid food, they preferred cereal that was flavored with carrot juice. So the flavor of carrots goes into the [breast milk], the babies experience it, and then they have all of these wonderful, positive feelings about carrot. " - Bee Wilson

4 to 7 Months:

Beginning at 4 months, the “flavor window” opens up. Babies will be open to new flavors and even though not much nutrition needs to be derived from them, this early exposure can make them more open minded as toddlers.

According to Bee Wilson, author of First Bite, researchers who study the science of picky eating disagree with the recommendation of the World Health Organization, which currently says you should keep babies on an exclusive milk diet for up to 6 months. 

She explains why babies on an exclusive milk diet during the first 6 months might be missing the boat when it comes to accepting new flavors: 

"It's not that a child necessarily needs any nutrition besides milk before 6 months, it's that you're missing an opportunity to introduce them to all of these flavors which they would likely accept at this age. Then, having accepted them, they would seem familiar when they encounter them again as toddlers" - Bee Wilson

From 8 Months:

The flavor window is starting to close, so continue exposing your child to new foods, without the pressure to eat them in a “messy play” type scenario. These repeated exposures will continue building up the familiarity that’s needed to accept the food.

"It's not that the flavor window then flips shut ... and we can never learn to love bitter green vegetables. Humans can learn to love new flavors at any age " - Bee Wilson

1 to 3 Years 

Expect pickiness to develop. It’s both genetic and instinctual. Continue trying food without the pressure to eat, but also start hiding veggies. Though texture will be lost, flavor exposure will still happen, and of course nutrition as well.

"Adding puréed vegetables to favorite foods led 3- to 6-year-olds to consume almost twice as many vegetables (and 11 percent fewer calories) over the course of a day. The preschoolers also accepted the dishes enhanced with vegetables as much as the dishes served in their regular form" -Barbara Rolls, PhD 

Key to the 1 to 3 Year Window:

We designed a refillable squeeze pouch (which can be pre-ordered here on Kickstarter) specifically to help you sneak more veggies into your toddler’s diet.
We rely upon pre-orders from Kickstarter to bring this product to life and make it right here in the USA. If you pre-order on Kickstarter, you’ll receive the cup in October.

Leave a comment

Pre-Order The Toddler Tumbler Today!

The Only Non-Plastic Sippy That’s Made in the USA

The 3-in-1 silicone design makes this product: An indestructible sippy/straw cup, a refillable food pouch, and a snack cup.

By pre-ordering the Toddler Tumbler on Kickstarter, you’ll help us raise the money we need upfront to afford to manufacture here in the US.

And in return, you’ll be the first to get the product, and you’ll get it at a hefty discount!

Toddler Tumbler

Back our second product on Kickstarter!

All pieces of the Toddler Tumbler are Mason Jar and Mason Bottle compatible

Mason Bottle

Shop Our Instagram

@faustisland just bought a pack of Mason Bottle Silicone Nipples, and then combined one with a classic blue mason jar she had at home. Extra adorable! uses Mason Bottle Silicone Sleeves to make toddler training cups for her big girls.

@headygrimm gets a Mason Bottle + Silicone Sleeve ready for her little one. She got the whole bottle including the jar as part of the Essential Mason Bottle Gift Set, but you can also make your own with jars from home using the Mason Bottle DIY Kit.

@loveandcovenant uses the 8 oz DIY Kit in combination with their mason jars from home.

@eyecreate_ gave her little lade The Original Mason Bottle. The width of mason jars makes them easy to hold for little hands.

@headygrimm got the Essential Mason Bottle Gift Set for her little one. It comes with both size bottles, both sleeves, and set of extra set of Medium Flow Nipples.

Paola used Mason Bottle with her son Max from the day they brought him home from the NICU. Though he didn't take to the preemie nipples in the hospital, he latched onto his Mason Bottle immediately!

@sriesland stocked up on mason jars for pumping at work, then she got a Mason Bottle DIY Kit to turn those jars into baby bottles.

@MasonBottle we like to use our 4 oz. sleeves with baby food portions.

Why Moms Love Us


Made in the USA

"I wish I knew about these before I had my shower, and avoiding all the plastic bottles I ended up with. They will also make great glasses after bottle use is over. Also happy to see the Made in the USA mark on the product as well." -Cathryn


Easy to Clean

"The next best thing to breastfeeding and the world's best shower gift! I love that I will never again have to buy a baby bottle because I already have tons of mason jars and they are so easy to clean. Our little guy loves his bottle!" -Susan


Breast Like Shape

"The nipples are very wide, like on an actual breast, and our daughter really liked them. Early on, she would suck really hard on the other nipples and make a very strange noise. As soon as we changed over to these her feeding became effortless." -Denielle

Our Most Popular Feeding Tips

Featured On

featured featured featured